Event graphic for PoP BC Briefing: Knowledge is Power, so Why is BC Hiding COVID-19 DataÉ

Want to keep track of our work? Sign up for PoP BC updates, actions, public health information, and announcements.

Knowledge is Power: So Why is BC Hiding COVID-19 Data?


The BC government claims to be as transparent on the pandemic as any jurisdiction in North America; is this true?

The BC Government has announced it will be removing some of the few remaining protections against Covid-19, despite ongoing uncertainty over the trajectory of current cases and the possibility of new variants. The strong signal to the public, organizations and businesses is that they must make their own risk assessments going forward. However, such assessments are hampered by restrictions on testing of all kinds, along with suppression of data such as case rates, hospitalization numbers, and outbreaks  in schools.

The B.C.’s government’s lack of transparency has led to the Canadian Association of Journalists awarding Premier John Horgan, Minister of Citizens’ Services Lisa Beare, and the provincial government of B.C. the  “Code of Silence Award for Outstanding Achievement in Government Secrecy” in the provincial category. 

Despite calls for greater data collection and transparency, we are seeing these critical public health tools trending in the opposite direction. Reducing and restricting public PCR testing and limiting access to rapid tests means we are in the dark regarding the true case count. Actual hospitalization data is nebulous, with patients admitted for Covid19 still removed from lists when deemed non-infectious despite undergoing treatment. Mortality, as analyzed and reported by Dr. Tara Moriarty, suggests BC might be undercounting deaths by as much as 78%. 

Government and Public Health have a duty to provide information that will provide clarity and timely data for families, business and organizations if they are to make risk assessments for themselves, employees and clients. Without access to public health data, we risk increasing the spread of current and new variants, and increasing distrust in the Government’s handling of an ongoing pandemic emergency.

Journalism Professor Sean Holman and reporter Brishti Basu will join this Protect our Province panel on the challenges of obtaining timely data to support media coverage, on BC’s relative lack of public Covid-19 data compared to other provinces, and on the vital and urgent need for transparency in this time of abundant misinformation.

Brishti Basu is a journalist with Capital Daily, primarily covering social issues and the COVID-19 pandemic. Her work has appeared in VICE, the BBC, National Geographic, The Tyee and several other publications.

Sean Holman is Associate Professor and Wayne Crookes Professor of Environmental and Climate Journalism at the University of Victoria, a former investigative journalist, and the founding editor of the pioneering online investigative political news service Public Eye.

The discussion will be facilitated by Kerri Coombs, an independent documentary producer, founder of FireDance Media, PoP BC broadcast technician, and former privacy policy officer in the Freedom of Information unit for Cornwall Council in the UK.

Join Protect our Province BC for Briefing #11: Knowledge is Power: So Why is BC Hiding COVID-19 Data?

When: Tuesday, February 22, 2022

Time: 12:00-1:00 PST

Where: ProtectBC.ca/Livestream

Protect Our Province BC is a grassroots group of physicians, nurses, health scientists, health policy specialists and community advocates. We are working together to help people in BC stay safe by sharing accurate information about the COVID-19 pandemic in BC, and advocating for evidence-based policies. Our ultimate goal is to end this pandemic through a vaccines-plus strategy that includes ventilation, better masks, and improved testing and contact tracing.

Archived Briefings from Protect Our Province BC

Title image for briefing April 20 - COVID in the House: Protect Your Loved Ones
Wednesday, April 27th from 12:00-1:00 PDT What should you do if someone in your house tests positive for COVID-19? How do we prevent it from passing to loved ones in the household? Why should we care? Data is emerging that, due to variant mutations, COVID-19 reinfections are happening, even in highly-vaccinated countries. For that reason,… Continue reading COVID-19 in the House: How to Protect Your Loved Ones
Title image for Briefing 14 April 7, 2022 - COVID Doesn't Take Breaks, Neither Can We
Thursday, April 7 at 12:00 noon PDT Ignoring the 6th wave won’t stop it. What does the evidence say? Join Dr. Lyne Filiatrault, Dr. Brenda Hardie, and Gosia Gasperowicz, PhD, as they discuss what BC needs to do to lower community transmission as the most infectious strain of COVID ever becomes dominant across the globe.… Continue reading COVID-19 Doesn’t Take Breaks. Neither Can We.
Title image for Briefing 13: Ethics in Canada, March 23, 2022
Wednesday, March 23rd, 12:30-1:30 pm PT Join Canadian researcher and author Jon Parsons in a discussion with Protect our Province BC member Dr. Amy Tan about how Canada’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic amounts to a failure of ethical action.  The pandemic has brought issues with Canada’s governing systems and cultural identity into full view:… Continue reading Lack of Ethics: How Canada is Failing with COVID-19

More News from Protect Our Province BC

Post title - reinstate masks in public spaces
Protect Our Province BC, Safe Schools Coalition BC and BC School COVID Tracker are coming together to ask for mask protection in indoor public spaces, businesses, schools and on public transit in BC. The removal of BC’s mandated health protections has us concerned for the health and well-being of all British Columbians. “Now that masking… Continue reading Protect Our Province BC, Safe Schools Coalition BC and BC School COVID Tracker Issue Joint Press Release
translink masking open meeting title image
On March 11th, the British Columbia Public Health Officer, Dr. Bonnie Henry lifted the indoor mask mandate for most public places, with the main exception being healthcare settings.  TransLink immediately followed suit and lifted its own mask requirement, leaving commuters on  buses and trains with very few COVID-19 precautions. Unlike BC, Ontario and Quebec have… Continue reading Transit Users Ask Translink to Keep Mask Protections in Place.
Title image for blog April 2 - N95 masks and transmission
Share this: April 2, 2022  A Guest Post by Tim Henthorne, B.A.Sc., P. Eng Over the past two years, we have been flooded with opinions regarding the wearing of masks, all while trying to learn how to deal with the existential threat of COVID-19. Unfortunately, much confusion has come from Public Health itself with its… Continue reading N95 Masks & the Transmission of COVID-19